Many of us at at the table felt the same way but as is the way the Judge has final say. That is why I am hoping that someone here is intimate with the rules and can at least clarify if it was handles correctly.The dealer/player in question went on to make the final table and went out as the bubble. No extra points and no cash so maybe there was a bit of justice in the end but still feel sorry for the guy he knocked out if the situation was handles incorrectly.