Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

My brother asked me to post this for him so he can get some responses before he turns this in. He already has had two papers posted on the school website that weren't half as important as this issue, so I figure there is a decent chance that this could be a bunch of people's first look at this issue. So if there is an important point that he should add, please let me know. Also, its in word format, so the paragraphs and spacing may be off on here. Thanks.I guess I should have added that this is for a Journalism class. So obviously the style of writing is different than a regular paper. This could be read by more than one person.The ill-conceived ban of online pokerBy Jake Williams “The internet is not something that you just dump something on. It’s not a big truck. It’s a series of tubes.” These words from Senator Ted Stevens (R-Alaska) are nothing short of baffling but Stevens, who heads the Senate Commerce Committee that regulates ecommerce, didn’t stop there. “Internet was sent by my staff at 10 o’clock in the morning on Friday and I just got it (Tuesday). Why?” Jon Stewart knows why. “Maybe it’s because you don’t seem to know jack-**** about computers or the internet. But that’s okay. You’re just the guy in charge of regulating it.” Tragically, the senior senator’s comments are not the most inexplicable government actions in recent months. We all know about the war in Iraq and other actions that have caused our president’s approval rating to plunge to near 30 percent, but another example has gone virtually unacknowledged: the recent government ban of online gambling. Debacles like these should remind us that public action is the check and balance against lousy governing. The Unlawful Gambling Enforcement Act (UGEA), passed by the U.S. Senate on September 30, is Title VIIII of the entirely unrelated Safe Port Act, which deals with port security. Widely unnoticed by the American public, the Act was unseen by the majority of senators voting on it. This is because it was attached to the Safe Port Act in such a way that, according to Senator Frank Lautenberg (D-NJ), nobody on the Senate-House Conference Committee saw the final language before it was passed. The Act is a fairly involved piece of legislation but its goal is to end the practice, use, and existence of online gambling in America by prohibiting money transfers to the websites that allow it. (That means the Act only affects poker when money is involved. Playing ‘for fun’ can continue.) It not only holds the gamblers responsible for their actions, but also places liability on the financial institutions that process their deposits and withdrawals. Without these institutions’ involvement, the multibillion dollar industry is expected to go bust. Indeed, several online poker sites have already suspended play. Poker websites, the primary victims of this legislation, have been targeted for playing a major role in this decade’s poker explosion. Prior to the internet, playing required either a poker night with friends or a trip to Las Vegas. Now a player can get online in just seconds and compete with players all around the world. This convenience has affected other areas as well, including television coverage and offline play. Both have experienced increased volume since online poker became popular. According to emediawire.com, poker is the third most watched sporting event in America, trailing only auto racing and football. In 2000, there were roughly 5,000 entrants in the World Series of Poker. By 2005 there were 23,000 entrants. The Poker Players Alliance estimates that 70 million Americans are playing. Were playing… The Act’s supporters feel gambling has adverse effects in numerous ways, including Senator Bill Frist’s (R-Tennessee) idea that gambling sites have been used by terrorists to launder money. He offers no proof, but his scare tactic (reminiscent of 1950’s Senator Joseph McCarthy’s communism ploy) has apparently worked. Supporters think Americans would be better off without corrupting and bankrupting games of chance. They argue poker players become deceptive and financially irresponsible and that the long hours spent playing are nothing short of negligence towards players’ families. Opponents of the Act point out poker’s many positive aspects, including its importance to the nation’s economy. Professional poker players, just like other professionals, provide for their families while paying income tax on their earnings. Casinos and online sites also pay taxes, and lots of them. Most Americans work long hours to provide for their families, but poker players have the unmerited image of negligence if gambling is what puts food on their tables. Also, Americans should have the freedom to seek entertainment however they want as long as it doesn’t hurt others, after all, this country was founded on the principle that people are mature enough to make responsible decisions. Finally, gamblers find comments about deception ironic when they come from politicians. Online gambling does have some issues to sort out, but prohibition is not the right solution. America is wasting an opportunity to raise vast federal and state revenues. On July 11, Judy Xanthopoulos, who holds a PhD in economics, released the findings of her study on internet poker. She concluded that more than $3 billion could be raised as taxes if the industry were properly regulated. That’s right, $3 billion. Considering the Congressional Budget Office announced that the federal deficit stands at $250 billion, online poker could pay off just over one percent our current fiscal deficit. America should exploit poker’s popularity.Our government missing this opportunity to its pay its bills through regulation is outrageous and contrary to global trends. Eighty countries already regulate internet poker, most notably our big brother, the United Kingdom, which passed legislation in 2005 to regulate and tax the industry. Our government needs to either repeal the Act or amend it to allow for online gambling. The latter is more likely to occur, as the Act already includes loopholes for wagering on horseracing, intrastate lotteries, and fantasy sports. Now that the Act has been passed, our government officials need to know how wrong they are. We can’t wait until funding for education, welfare, or other essential programs (like bomb-building) suffers. There are two ways the average citizen can get involved with minimal effort. First, write or call your congressmen if you disagree with this legislation because only action will cause a reaction. Second, join an organization dedicated to lobbying the issue in Washington. One such group, the Poker Players Alliance, already has 75,000 members. Americans have the power to influence the legislation we must obey. The aspiration of democracy is to protect civil liberties, but in an age when we send our troops abroad to restore basic rights our own government is working to deprive Americans of them. How far will we let our country slide before taking action? The time has come to exercise the right to petition our legislators as guaranteed by the United States Constitution. At least our government got that bill right.

Posted

It seemed well thought out, well composed, and had valid points. What the hell is it doing in General??

Posted
It seemed well thought out, well composed, and had valid points. What the hell is it doing in General??
QFT +++++111111 :club::D:D:D:):):):club: on a serious note, nice paper.
Posted

I could be wrong, but his opening paragraph is a bit...strong. And using quotes with expletives probably won't go over too well with administration. I would use that quote in a subsequent paragraph, or at least insert something instead of an expletive, like he doesn't know [very much]...But other than that, decent.

Posted
...example has gone virtually unacknowledged: the recent government ban of online gambling. Debacles like these ...
from what i've gathered over the last couple weeks, this is inaccurate. the bill didn't change anything concerning the legality of gaming, it only made it illegal for financial institutions to have transactions with gambling site. the government is trying to make it harder to gamble online, regardless of legality.the current legality of online gambling is subject to laws passed prior to this one, whether they allow/deny/do not apply.i think allyn shulman covered everything in a pretty good article at cardplayer (search the board, there was a link).also he should mention that a lot of credit card companies and banks have been self policing and denying these transactions for some time, in the interest of giving complete information.otherwise good article.
Posted

Lincoln: I will tell him to change that to 'The Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act of 2006 'Jeepster: Both of his previous articles that were posted on the school site had language that I thought would have kept it off the site. I like your suggestion and have seen it done before, so I will suggest he change that. His reasoning for using the quote to start it off was to try to catch the attention of anyone who glances at the article. There are less of us poker players in Utah, so he thought that it was a good way to get them to read further. I will pass your comments on to him though.Thanks again for the responses.

Posted

The ideas and concepts are fine, but from a composition standpoint it fails miserably. This looks more like an opinionated rant then a composed paper that is being turned in to an educator. Too many quotes, no citations, no real organization or flow to speak of. You really need to develop and thesis statement and follow through with it. The paper also ends abruptly with no tie in to the relevance of the first paragraph. Be concise, the President; approval rating and the war have no relevance in this paper and take away from the main point you are trying to make.As for the importance of this article - it's really only important to all of us who play poker and that is a very, very, very small portion of this country's population. Don't let the "millions of people playing poker" claims fool you; they are talking about people who sit and play once or twice a year or try to play 3 person $5 tournaments and such, not the collective dedicated poker playing community. GL, my $.02P.S. - I'm basing my suggestions on the assumption that he's in high school? If this is a college paper you have enen more problems.

from what i've gathered over the last couple weeks, this is inaccurate. the bill didn't change anything concerning the legality of gaming, it only made it illegal for financial institutions to have transactions with gambling site. the government is trying to make it harder to gamble online, regardless of legality.the current legality of online gambling is subject to laws passed prior to this one, whether they allow/deny/do not apply.i think allyn shulman covered everything in a pretty good article at cardplayer (search the board, there was a link).also he should mention that a lot of credit card companies and banks have been self policing and denying these transactions for some time, in the interest of giving complete information.otherwise good article.
This is a good point as well - online gambling has not been banned
Posted
Thank you for the compliments. I will pass them on. Any important points that need to be added?
hey if you could would you mind pming me your brothers info or a way to get in contact with himi am actually writing my law school directed research paper on this very issue. most of it focuses on how the USA government could regulate this based on the UK model. i have also attacked the present bill. its about 20 pages right now i dont plan on making it much longer than that.i am just curious what his sites where and were he got some of his info.
Posted
hey if you could would you mind pming me your brothers info or a way to get in contact with himi am actually writing my law school directed research paper on this very issue. most of it focuses on how the USA government could regulate this based on the UK model. i have also attacked the present bill. its about 20 pages right now i dont plan on making it much longer than that.i am just curious what his sites where and were he got some of his info.
PM sent, I think. First PM so if it doesn't work let me know.
Posted
hey if you could would you mind pming me your brothers info or a way to get in contact with himi am actually writing my law school directed research paper on this very issue. most of it focuses on how the USA government could regulate this based on the UK model. i have also attacked the present bill. its about 20 pages right now i dont plan on making it much longer than that.i am just curious what his sites where and were he got some of his info.
Can the government regulate/tax this if the site is in a foreign country?I think the problem isn't gambling per se, it's how can the US government tax a company in another country, if there are no tangible goods crossing the borders?Really we need to define what the internet is, in an economic sense. I already understand the series of tubes analogy.
Posted
Can the government regulate/tax this if the site is in a foreign country?I think the problem isn't gambling per se, it's how can the US government tax a company in another country, if there are no tangible goods crossing the borders?Really we need to define what the internet is, in an economic sense. I already understand the series of tubes analogy.
yes the government could. (i will explain as short and simple as possible)first the gov. would issue a license to certain companies like party poker or fcp there would be long process with verification and such to get licensed. the law could go so far as to say the only advertising in the states for online gambling would be for only those licensed. it is true that there would be other online sites trying to get business but only those licensed would be "endorsed" by the federal government which would basically move all the american business to those companies (all the action)once they are licensed we move to step two Compliance. Ideally there would be an online gaming comission (like any state gambling commission) and they would have set up standards that a company must follow to keep there license. some things the commission could to is conduct periodic visits to the site and perform unannouced test on the sites RNG to make sure the games are fair. there are several other things the commission could and would do but above are some examblesFinally the gov. would have to set up enforcement statutes to allow law enforcement to investigate and prosecute certain activities and violations. punishments for such violations could result in lose of licensing.There may be some issues with states right so there would have to be some sort of way a state could be able to pass a law in which there state would not allow there players to play.Also one may say well how can the government enforce standards on an overseas company. maybe they wouldnt but the threat of losing the govs. "endorsement" would make them follow the standards. Moreover, it is not a far fetched idea to assume that if the gov. did something like this most land based casinos already in the U.S. (like harrahs, mgm) would jump into the market. If they did then the gov. would have no problems punishing these companies as they are American companines already.
Posted
yes the government could. (i will explain as short and simple as possible)
Then I see this whole thing getting taken care of and online poker just having larger rakes in a short amount of time.But on the flip side we can be assured that there are no rigged sites, and we will be able to sue a company for screwing us.Which is the American dream
Posted
Then I see this whole thing getting taken care of and online poker just having larger rakes in a short amount of time.But on the flip side we can be assured that there are no rigged sites, and we will be able to sue a company for screwing us.Which is the American dream
yeah i really dont forsee this bill being around for ever and soon the gov. will have to regulate it because they will see all the money they are loosing by not doing so.but it wont be immediate. i think it would take atleast 4-5 years for it to change. just look at prohibition that took a while to change and that was drinking for god sakes. i know that actually involved a constitutional amendment, but regulating poker by the us gov will take a while
Posted

The bill as passed has nothing to do with gaming, gambling, morality or poker. It has everything to do with protectionism. If it were American companies being affected then there would be no bill.The USA has a long and unenviable history of imposing free markets by force upon other countries while locking out access to their own markets, especially when they're beaten in fair competition

Posted
The bill as passed has nothing to do with gaming, gambling, morality or poker. It has everything to do with protectionism. If it were American companies being affected then there would be no bill.The USA has a long and unenviable history of imposing free markets by force upon other countries while locking out access to their own markets, especially when they're beaten in fair competition
I thought it was the other way around, we give them free markets, and they lock us out.
Posted
I thought it was the other way around, we give them free markets, and they lock us out.
ahahahahahahaha *chokes*The normal pattern of events (and well known everywhere else in the world) is that the USA imposes unrestricted exploitation by US companies on other countries while keeping the US market closed, restricted and subject to extreme protectionism- for an example, see the online gaming billThat you believe that:- you are doing a good thing by "giving (countries) free markets"- the US tolerates anyone trying to favour indiginous productioncontrary to the facts is something that the US media should be very proud of*sigh*

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...