JackTheCat Posted March 1, 2005 Posted March 1, 2005 Hi all,I am a Christian who plays poker, and I do not find anything wrong with that as I am in control of my bankroll (well actually I am playing on other fishie's money lol). I have read the Bible (yes the whole thing, more than once) and have not found the "thou shalt not play cards or gamble" commandment. There are warnings about money and fools, if you know what I mean.The only thing I try to do is give my playing a rest on Sunday's as I play 6 days a week and anything over that would be an addiction right? lolI was wondering how many other PPC's are out there, and I don't mean the C&E church goers, (Christmas and Easter), I mean the ones that go every Sunday and look forward to it, are active in their faith and take any opportunity God gives them to share the good news of Jesus. (FYI, I am not a BIBLE THUMPER, I only respond if someone shows interest and asks me about it.) Thanks, JackTheCatand remember in poker as in Life,, "IT'S ALL GOOD!" :angel:
....Ian.... Posted March 1, 2005 Posted March 1, 2005 i go every sunday (or sat. vigil) and try to live my life the way God wants me to. Still though, i dont think playing poker is 'good' in God's eyes
JackTheCat Posted March 1, 2005 Author Posted March 1, 2005 Could you elaborate why you don't think playing poker is "good" in God's eyes.I look upon my playing as hobby, which I happen to make money while enjoying the analytical and social aspects of the game.I don't see much of a difference between my hobby and other peoples', such as gardening, scrapbooking or the many other hobbies that people spend tons of money on.Oh, and did I mention, I give 10% of my winnings to my church or charities. Also, if you are thinking that Jesus wouldn't hang out in a casino with poker playing gamblers, you may want to check out who He did hang out with...Just my opinion, and I thank you for your response.JackTheCat"IT'S ALL GOOD!"
TheIceman05 Posted March 1, 2005 Posted March 1, 2005 I happen to agree that God likely wouldn't judge poker as a virtuous activity, for the following reasons.1) Greed- The sole aim of a good poker player is to make money. Perhaps your motivations are different (competition, skill, etc), but they're still likely sinful (pride, etc.). 2) Your time could be better spent. God does not smile on the lazy man, who fills his days with an empty activity. As much as I love poker, it's absolutely worthless in terms of any possible social ends. Just because you give 10% of your winnings to charity doesn't really change that.3) Poker is a zero-sum game. To be successful, SOMEONE ELSE MUST BE UNSUCCESSFUL. This is a problem, tantamount to rooting for the failure of others. This is not nice. This is not nice at all4) The people you assosciate with. Yes, Jesus did assosciate with some relatively shady characters, but this is mitigated by the followinga) he is the son of GodB) he was spreading peace and love on EarthI imagine you are neither related to God in anyway, nor are you having some positive impact upon the lives of the sinners with which you surround yourself daily. Personally, I'm not not religious at all, but if there is a God, he's probably "tsk tsk"ing you for being a poker player.Ice
Tritz Posted March 1, 2005 Posted March 1, 2005 10% WOW...The church is going to retire off of you!You are taking the VIP lane to heaven.....just kidding, that's very noble.
epistemic Posted March 1, 2005 Posted March 1, 2005 hmm, I would say I'm a PPA, poker playing atheist, or even a poker playing apatheist. But that might imply a rejection of theism as though somehow there are grounds for theism in the first place. Nope, i'm only a devotee of free markets and free minds, and poker is a virtuous microcosm of that.
faketree Posted March 1, 2005 Posted March 1, 2005 I don't think God is immune to the recent poker craze. He's probably playing no-limit hold'em against elvis, JFK, ghandi, jimi hendrix, etc.I mean, talk about the 'BIG GAME'!!!
opie Posted March 1, 2005 Posted March 1, 2005 I'm at least an every Sunday churchgoer.Christianity has been used to justify wars as well as complete pacifism. It has been used to justify voluntary poverty (e.g. nuns take a vow of poverty) as well as that it is OK to be rich. It is up to you to apply your Christian principles as best you can.Greed is bad. Being generous with your money is good.Laziness is bad. Recreation (and rest) is good.You figure it out.Personally, I call poker recreation, and I'm not playing for high enough stakes to cause me any financial problems and hopefully not for anyone else either.Peace,Opie
JackTheCat Posted March 1, 2005 Author Posted March 1, 2005 in response to Iceman05, First of all, I am not greedy, in fact I often miss bets I should be collecting on the river.. Also the fact that I donate part of my profits seems to mitigate the greed factor for me personnally. Also I consider it a part time job/hobby and as such I am here to make money. The risk associated with putting money into the stock market is really gambling on a company, I choose to put my money into a known quantity, myself.Second, I do not think that poker is an empty or mindless activity without any social value. If you think that, what is golf? I study the game and keep my mind sharp at all times while playing.Also, playing poker does have social value as I am interacting with other people and I am a very nice poker player, meaning, I would never swear at anyone or call them an idiot. I think there should be more of my type at the tables.. it would be more pleasant for some. I do like witty banter with a touch of sarcasm though.You seem to have a problem with the game and the zero-sum aspect of it. For every game there is but one winner and the rest are losers, but in poker there can be many winners at the table. Does your comment suggest that you find all games or competition "not nice"?I think throwing Christians to the Lions was not a good game.I appreciate your banter.. JackTheCat"IT'S ALL GOOD!"
gadjet Posted March 1, 2005 Posted March 1, 2005 I'm an active Christian and take my personal faith very seriously, I love God and wow Iceman I'm impressed you have a very good understanding of the whole thing, I'd love to sit down and debate with you someday…The Zero sum aspect is a huge one for me, I absolutely love the game of Poker, but knowing that there are many people that are addicted, and losing money they can't afford to makes it very difficult for me to justify. I emailed DN about this and he sent a great email and said he was going to write a blog about it but I disagreed with a couple of his points… I still haven't come to any conclusions I play at a table in my city that's full of rich retired dudes, so I'm okay with winning their money because that's a part of the game. Winning at poker against people who are addicted is taking advantage of them and there is no way that it pleases God, winning at poker against rich business dudes on the other hand I feel is okay. DN brought up the point that it's very similar to the stock market in a sense which I can see, he also made the argument (which I feel is quite a stretch) that all professional sports players are taking money from each other… i.e. if Shaq gets 20 million there's a few players lower down that lose out… Ice also brought up the use of time thing… it's not so much that poker is a bad anti-social activity, it's more that it occupies a lot of time that could be put to better use. Poker also tends to occupy my mind a lot… and while God comes first for me, I do think about poker hands throughout the day when my mind could be on serving God.I would agree that I'm definitely not attracted to poker through greed. I really do love the game itself… so for now I've decided to continue playing, with a positive mindset and trying to be a good reflection of God even at the poker table and I really am starting to look at it as a job which I love. And I tithe from my winnings to.
aneurysm Posted March 1, 2005 Posted March 1, 2005 What is this the Ontario thread?I am by no means a Christian. However, if I was, I would not play poker. Aspects of the game are "sinful" including (as mentioned previously) greed. But Christian doctrine is irrelavent. Right-wing Christian society has a problem with gambling. This shouldn't be important but it is. To the original poster: I invite you to tell the members of your clergy where your donations come from .
gadjet Posted March 1, 2005 Posted March 1, 2005 What is this the Ontario thread?I am by no means a Christian. However, if I was, I would not play poker. Aspects of the game are "sinful" including (as mentioned previously) greed. But Christian doctrine is irrelavent. Right-wing Christian society has a problem with gambling. This shouldn't be important but it is. To the original poster: I invite you to tell the members of your clergy where your donations come from .Yes but that logic any job or even game can be considered sinful, it is all in the mindset that you approach the game, and I believe that this continues on into poker. But I do agree about telling the church where the money came from… it would be interesting to see the result…
jeff_536 Posted March 1, 2005 Posted March 1, 2005 haven't we had this discussion about 10 times already??Groundhog Day.
Randall Flagg Posted March 1, 2005 Posted March 1, 2005 I happen to agree that God likely wouldn't judge poker as a virtuous activity, for the following reasons.1) Greed- The sole aim of a good poker player is to make money. Perhaps your motivations are different (competition, skill, etc), but they're still likely sinful (pride, etc.). IceThis statement asserts that anybody who undertakes an activity with the intent of making money is sinful. Since a large majority of adults have jobs, as they did in Biblical times as well, I find this theory laughably unpersuasive.2) Your time could be better spent. God does not smile on the lazy man, who fills his days with an empty activity. As much as I love poker, it's absolutely worthless in terms of any possible social ends. Just because you give 10% of your winnings to charity doesn't really change that.IceThis theory seems to be communist, not Biblical. We could get into a discussion of the societal benefits of leisure time, but the argument that hobbies and vacations are sinful isn't worth the time.3) Poker is a zero-sum game. To be successful, SOMEONE ELSE MUST BE UNSUCCESSFUL. This is a problem, tantamount to rooting for the failure of others. This is not nice. This is not nice at allIceThis definition includes every sporting event, where one side's win necessitates another's loss. Or, presidential elections are bad, since Bush's win necessitated Kerry's loss.4) The people you assosciate with. Yes, Jesus did assosciate with some relatively shady characters, but this is mitigated by the followinga) he is the son of GodB) he was spreading peace and love on EarthThere's a circular logic problem here. Poker players must be "shady" because they associate with other poker players, who by the way I have decided are shady.Personally, I'm not not religious at all, but if there is a God, he's probably "tsk tsk"ing you for being a poker player.IceNo, he loves you very much and he hopes that you use the intelligence he gave you to throw away your gutshot draw on the turn.
....Ian.... Posted March 1, 2005 Posted March 1, 2005 Could you elaborate why you don't think playing poker is "good" in God's eyes.I believe that any form of gambling is wrong. Just my beliefs.
Devilkin Posted March 1, 2005 Posted March 1, 2005 I believe that any form of gambling is wrong. Just my beliefs.Life is gambling . . statistally you have a minute chance of dying by getting in your car and driving on the highway. Its all about risk vs reward.Gambling FOR MONEY seems to be where the line is drawn at . .heck I'd rather the second example than the first. Lose in my first example, you can lost body parts. Second example I lose a few bucks.Care to elaborate why its 'wrong', other than its your 'belief'?Dev"Faith is what we use when logic doesn't give us the answers we want to hear'
HtotheNootch Posted March 1, 2005 Posted March 1, 2005 Oddly enough, there's a Jewish festival called Purim (check me on the spelling - I'm not Jewish just took classes about it in college) that probably dates back even further than Jesus' time where the whole point was to drink and gamble. Jesus being a good Jew, probably participated.Just an interesting thought.
Quagmire Posted March 1, 2005 Posted March 1, 2005 I've been a Catholic/Christian for most of my life (the college years found me at church only rarely), but now attend faithfully every week. I've been a serious poker player for the past 2 1/2 years, and continually reflect on whether that is consistent with God's wishes for man.It is hard to say that gambling would find favor in God's eyes. It is by nature deceitful (although I never bluff), a poor example of stewardship of the money God has provided, and a poor use of the time that could be better spent on other things. However, I balance that thought process with the idea that I am what God made me, and that is an analytical, competitive, assertive person. I am applying my time and talents to that which I am skilled at. What I have decided is that I am a sinful person (for reasons other than card playing), and that I am in need of God's forgiveness and providence everyday. But, I am also providing for my family, and do not sacrifice the well being of my family for the enjoyment of a game. We pay our bills, donate to charity, spend time on other fun activities, and travel as a family on the wages from my job. My poker playing is independent of that.To the point that poker players spend their time with less than savory characters, I would say that is immaterial. Ever been to a football or hockey game? The crowds are no worse there. Plus, I've played in a number of tournaments where I've worn my crucifix necklace on the outside of my shirt, and have generated numerous religious discussions at the tables. So, if nothing else, everyone else at the table was hearing about Christ while they played. Some would call that obtrusive. I call it witnessing.
Randall Flagg Posted March 1, 2005 Posted March 1, 2005 Oddly enough, there's a Jewish festival called Purim (check me on the spelling - I'm not Jewish just took classes about it in college) that probably dates back even further than Jesus' time where the whole point was to drink and gamble. Jesus being a good Jew, probably participated.Just an interesting thought.Not to mention Hanukkah, where we spin the dreydel. As a people, Jews definitely do their fair share of gambling. If I ever run a casino, I think I'll open a Dreydel table.
JackTheCat Posted March 1, 2005 Author Posted March 1, 2005 I do not hide the fact that I play poker from my church community. I go to a Baptist church, and I play the drums for our worship music at the beginning of the services. And by the way, I am a chick drummer.. I give 10% of my paychecque from my regular job as well as my poker career/hobby.I think there are a lot of misconceptions floating around, that if you are a Christian you can't have fun or enjoy yourself. I really liked your comments Randall Flagg, and the gadget, and I do feel bad for people with any kind of addiction, but I don't think that by me not playing it would help anyone with this kind of problem. If anyone who had a problem spoke with me about it, I would certainly try to help them. I also remember that I am in a place that only adults can play, and we all have to be responsible for ourselves as adults.I personally don't have a problem with what I do and who I am as a Chrsitian.JackTheCat
NikolaiPutin Posted March 1, 2005 Posted March 1, 2005 The problem with gambling for the Christian as I see it, is the issue of stuardship. If I believe that all my money is the result of God's blessing, whether it be my talents that my employer pays me for, or the money that I stumble into some other way, then it is probably not the best way to thank Him by doing something speculative with it when there are people who could benefit from my money in some other way. On the other hand if you feel than God wants you out to be with poker players sharing the good news, that he sent His son to die in our place, and he is alive today... well I guess that is something else. The way I rationalize it is that I am going to win in the long run so its not like I am really gambling :-) I thought the following little snippet fit in here. Warning Bible verses follow you've been warned:Romans 14:18-23 18 For he that in these things serveth Christ is acceptable to God, and approved of men. 19 Let us therefore follow after the things which make for peace, and things wherewith one may edify another. 20 For meat destroy not the work of God. All things indeed are pure; but it is evil for that man who eateth with offence. 21 It is good neither to eat flesh, nor to drink wine, nor any thing whereby thy brother stumbleth, or is offended, or is made weak. 22 Hast thou faith? have it to thyself before God. Happy is he that condemneth not himself in that thing which he alloweth. 23 And he that doubteth is damned if he eat, because he eateth not of faith: for whatsoever is not of faith is sin.God Bless and :spadesa: :spadesk: :spadesq: :spadesj: :spades10: to you all.
BigMoney74 Posted March 1, 2005 Posted March 1, 2005 Hi all,I am a Christian who plays poker, and I do not find anything wrong with that as I am in control of my bankroll (well actually I am playing on other fishie's money lol). I have read the Bible (yes the whole thing, more than once) and have not found the "thou shalt not play cards or gamble" commandment. There are warnings about money and fools, if you know what I mean.The only thing I try to do is give my playing a rest on Sunday's as I play 6 days a week and anything over that would be an addiction right? lolI was wondering how many other PPC's are out there, and I don't mean the C&E church goers, (Christmas and Easter), I mean the ones that go every Sunday and look forward to it, are active in their faith and take any opportunity God gives them to share the good news of Jesus. (FYI, I am not a BIBLE THUMPER, I only respond if someone shows interest and asks me about it.) Thanks, JackTheCatand remember in poker as in Life,, "IT'S ALL GOOD!" :angel:I have no opinion, but here is a link.http://www.bible.com/answers/agamblin.html
Tparks86 Posted March 1, 2005 Posted March 1, 2005 I'm definitely a PPC. The Bible doesn't come out and say anything about "gambling" or anything of that direct nature. I think that the real issue is money. It's the same thing with any job. If you're consumed with just making money and more money, then you have issues. If I'm taking money from someone and putting it to good use: Friends in need, poor, charity, church etc. And I myselt, am being wise with my money, I don't see the difference.
gadjet Posted March 1, 2005 Posted March 1, 2005 quote="Randall Flagg"] 3) Poker is a zero-sum game.  To be successful' date=' SOMEONE ELSE MUST BE UNSUCCESSFUL.  This is a problem, tantamount to rooting for the failure of others.  This is not nice.  This is not nice at allIce[/quote']This definition includes every sporting event, where one side's win necessitates another's loss. Or, presidential elections are bad, since Bush's win necessitated Kerry's loss.This is a very big stretch to justify it… we are talking about individual loss. There are people that are betting money they shouldn't (rent, food etc) in hopes of winning. It is a much more direct zero-sum activity… we're not talking about losing a game, there are people losing everything on gambling… and to Jack the Cat (I love chick Drummers) I think saying well me not playing would help anyone with their addiction is not the best argument because I could say that about a strip club or something… well I might as well go, because even if I didn't go it wouldn’t help people who spend all their time there (you see?)…Anyways I think my answer is along the lines of the whole Is poker really gambling debate… it's all a matter of personal bounderies though… I have a few Christian friends who are absolutely addicted to gambling… and I try to help them… but if they see me winning and playing often there's not much I can do as an example to them short of quitting. I do agree that the whole we are adults and not completely responsible for each other though…I drum at my Church for worship too!I think DN's example of his generosity and that he feels he has been given that much money to help people is an awesome thing.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now