Goodfellas Vs. Casino

[chrozzo 19]

Im trying to decide which one to watch (i'll probably watch them both anyways) I love both, just am really bored and am interested in which ones you all prefer and why.

[SAM_Hard8 44]

Are you kidding me? You must be sick.Goodfellas AINEC

[strategy 4]

pretty sure goodfellas is the consensus regardless of what you get from this poll.I like casino, too. I once watched a documentary on the history channel or somesuch with the guy it's based on. I don't think I could have made it out of his situation.

[nickforgot 0]

goodfellas, end of discussion

[grocery_mony 8]

As far back as I can remember, I always wanted to be a gangster.

[SuitedAces21 2,721]

pretty sure goodfellas is the consensus regardless of what you get from this poll.I like casino, too. I once watched a documentary on the history channel or somesuch with the guy it's based on. I don't think I could have made it out of his situation.

in the end, strat, you could always pick a winner.

[bleacherbum3 8]

Goodfellas AINEC

Yup.

[mtdesmoines 3]

"We'll pick up a shovel at my motha's house."

[keith crime 8]

the two stories are so similar that just coming first means that goodfellas is the better moviepesci's roles are almost identical - although it sounds like he was a perfect fit for both roles especially the guy he plays in casino - anthony spilatro i thinkcasino sort of breaks down in the sharon stone deniro relationshipyou just don't care and you also never believe for a second that pesci and stone would ever get it on and if they did you certainly didn't want to see itI love that scene where Pesci is playing blackjack and keeps making the dealer give him a different card as Don Rickles watches knowing all hell has broken looseI also love the line where Deniro tells the politician - either he's incompetant or he's a crook i don't know which but either way he can't work here anymore

[strategy 4]

in the end, strat, you could always pick a winner.

you jest, but I have indeed found the secret to picking winners.

[LongLiveYorke 38]

I picked Casino to be contrarian.Well, actually, I saw Casino first and have seen it more times than Goodfellas, so I think that has biased my thinking. Goodfellas is probably tighter and better, but Casino is just so darn entertaining to watch that I had to give it some love in the poll.

[GeneralGeeWhiz 0]

goodfellas > casino.casino was missing something. it just seemed that everyone was just walking through their parts and not acting their best. goodfellas is scorsese's best movie.

[strategy 4]

I picked Casino to be contrarian.Well, actually, I saw Casino first and have seen it more times than Goodfellas, so I think that has biased my thinking. Goodfellas is probably tighter and better, but Casino is just so darn entertaining to watch that I had to give it some love in the poll.

I actually voted casino as well.

[GeneralGeeWhiz 0]

I picked Casino to be contrarian.Well, actually, I saw Casino first and have seen it more times than Goodfellas, so I think that has biased my thinking. Goodfellas is probably tighter and better, but Casino is just so darn entertaining to watch that I had to give it some love in the poll.

casino isn't on the same level as goodfellas. not only scoreses's best, but one of the best movies of all time. casino was just missing something. 3 stars at most.

[aucu 3]

pretty sure goodfellas is the consensus regardless of what you get from this poll.I like casino, too. I once watched a documentary on the history channel or somesuch with the guy it's based on. I don't think I could have made it out of his situation.

That would be this guyhttp://frankrosenthal.com/

[runthemover 39]

I picked Casino to be contrarian.

I didn't even vote

[BigDMcGee 3,352]

I think good fellas, but I do think it's close. I think casino is an operatic tragedy that is just fantastic, and is illustrative of one of the classic blunder. The most famous is never get in a land war in asia, but only slightly less famous is this: never make a ho a house wife. It's problem is it's just a little too long. Goodfellas is lean, every scene is iconic, some of the shots are spectacular, the soundtrack, it's basically a perfect gangster movie. The only major problem is ray liotta is just terrible. The mark hamill of gangster movies.

[ajs510 122]

Now go home and get your fuckin' shinebox.

[leftygolfer 7]

Now go home and get your fuckin' shinebox.

Nice call back.I think the music was better in Goodfellas.There was a strip joint about 20 minutes from where I grew up called Michael's Magic Touch. It was Michael Spilotro's

[Dubey 1,035]

Voted Goodfellas. I think if Casino was made first, this poll would be closer.Both are fantastic movies.

[mtdesmoines 3]

I think good fellas, but I do think it's close. I think casino is an operatic tragedy that is just fantastic, and is illustrative of one of the classic blunder. The most famous is never get in a land war in asia, but only slightly less famous is this: never make a ho a house wife. It's problem is it's just a little too long. Goodfellas is lean, every scene is iconic, some of the shots are spectacular, the soundtrack, it's basically a perfect gangster movie. The only major problem is ray liotta is just terrible. The mark hamill of gangster movies.

I think Liotta did some really good things. And he's smarmy as all hell, which I thought was good for the part. I can't say he detracted from the movie.

[fleung22 1]

GoodfellasBut to be honest, after watching Casino I felt like it was Goodfellas 2 or some king of ripoff and never watched it again. Goodfellas I've seen like 30+ times

[brvheart 1,747]

I voted Casino.Goodfellas is another movie, like Reservoir Dogs, that I saw 15+ years after it's release that it simply couldn't hold up to 15 years of hype. It was mediocre for me. I like The Departed at least 10x more.

[BigDMcGee 3,352]

Goodfellas is another movie, like Reservoir Dogs, that I saw 15+ years after it's release that it simply couldn't hold up to 15 years of hype. It was mediocre for me. I like The Departed at least 10x more.

[SuitedAces21 2,721]

Goodfellas is another movie, like Reservoir Dogs, that I saw 15+ years after it's release that it simply couldn't hold up to 15 years of hype. It was mediocre for me. I like The Departed at least 10x more.

no, man, no.