iggymcfly Posted July 20, 2008 Posted July 20, 2008 I only really post in the monthly goals thread and the Omaha forum any more, but it seems like the traffic on FCP has been falling big time. You'll have whole forums that won't get any responses for days, even when they actually had something interesting to say. Just wondering if anyone else has been paying attention to this and is thinking that FCP's going to be dying for good soon.
Acid_Knight Posted July 20, 2008 Posted July 20, 2008 I tend to agree. I think part of it is the evolution of the players on the site. I used to post like 95% of all of my posts in the NL Strat forum. I would comment on every hand (hello post count) and try and help everyone. Over the last 2 years, I've grown more as a player and have started posting fewer and fewer hands of my own and I have even been commenting on far fewer posts because they seem to be the same XXXXX standard hands that the newer players just don't understand.I think that there's some strat being discussed in the challenge thread in the general forum where more of the NL players who play for higher stakes tend to post, but overall yeah, there's not as much traffic as there used to be.
uncooper Posted July 20, 2008 Posted July 20, 2008 The omaha forum goes in bursts. When people post hands there is plenty of good discussion. It does go days without new topics though.
CobaltBlue Posted July 20, 2008 Posted July 20, 2008 I think that there's some strat being discussed in the challenge thread in the general forum where more of the NL players who play for higher stakes tend to postYes, I blame Mark and Jordan also.
Snamuh Posted July 20, 2008 Posted July 20, 2008 I tend to agree. I think part of it is the evolution of the players on the site. I used to post like 95% of all of my posts in the NL Strat forum. I would comment on every hand (hello post count) and try and help everyone. Over the last 2 years, I've grown more as a player and have started posting fewer and fewer hands of my own and I have even been commenting on far fewer posts because they seem to be the same XXXXX standard hands that the newer players just don't understand.I think that there's some strat being discussed in the challenge thread in the general forum where more of the NL players who play for higher stakes tend to post, but overall yeah, there's not as much traffic as there used to be.This is 100% spot on. When I joined this site, I made 90% of my posts in the NL strat forum, both posting hands and commenting on everyone's hands. I now post all of my hands in the challenge thread, because that's where most of the better discussion is located. I don't post hands anymore in the NL strat forum because most of the MSNL+ players don't post there and I feel like some of the strategy is a few levels above most of the players posting there (not trying to sound arrogant when I type that because my thinking was pretty basic as well when I first started posting here, so the hands and advice I posted were fairly basic as well).It also pains me to say it but for SSNL+ strategy advice, 2p2 is like 100x better.
TravisG Posted July 20, 2008 Posted July 20, 2008 i don't know, they tourney donk forum seems to run pretty well.
Merby Posted July 20, 2008 Posted July 20, 2008 *checks for pulse*...*begins CPR*...The patient is stable for now, but that was too close...In all honesty, I agree. I used to post 90% in the NLHE and PLO strat forums... Now, I have ebbed in my strat postings. I will try to up the ante again.
gfdsa146 Posted July 20, 2008 Posted July 20, 2008 Uh, the stud forum probably has about a total of...6 to 8 people that post in it? And not very frequently
BudBundy Posted July 22, 2008 Posted July 22, 2008 I agree.We lack posters who has an opinion and will and time and attitude to defend it.Like smash.Good luck.
simo_8ball Posted July 22, 2008 Posted July 22, 2008 suggestions?Phase 1 - Lock the challenge thread for 24 hours.Phase 2 - ?Phase 3 - Profit
No_Neck Posted July 22, 2008 Posted July 22, 2008 I think a lot of us also have started IMing each other things that we use to post... to be honest I don't have that many questions on 6 max anymore, and all the other questions seem to be like I have KK and got min raised on the river? what do I do?
bdc30 Posted July 23, 2008 Posted July 23, 2008 suggestions?Move the challenge threads in to the particular strat forum they're associated to. They don't really belong in genpo - and maybe that would get some people active IN the strat forums just by being there all the time. Sticky a challenge thread at the top of each of the strat forums. Start some kind of community spirit for those playing each particular game. Start a heads up forum - seems that's the fastest growing segment of the online game today. I don't know about anyone else, but it frustrates me greatly to hear people say things like this:Over the last 2 years, I've grown more as a player and have started posting fewer and fewer hands of my own and I have even been commenting on far fewer posts because they seem to be the same XXXXX standard hands that the newer players just don't understand.We have to remember that we all started somewhere. Once upon a time WE ALL were the newer player who didn't understand some concept or way of thinking. The world of online poker today is a much different place than it was even two or three years ago. Yeah, some of the strat posts are basic - it doesn't take a lot to put a short blurb about what the right play is AND the fact that it's a pretty standard concept. I try to comment one way or other on EVERY thread posted in the omaha forum.I give a MASSIVE amount of credit to this forum and some of the posters on it who have been good enough to share their knowledge with me. I've reached out to a few guys asking for help with certain things, and the vast majority of the time, I've cultivated not only a new wealth of poker knowledge, but what I feel to be a true friendship with that person.Recently, I've also had a few others approach me about learning low limit plo. I know I'm no grand wizard of the game, but I have a good understanding of the fundamentals and basic concepts. I try to do everything I can to help these players - I've even pm'd some that appear to be having trouble with some of the basics. I do this because I know what I've taken FROM this forum and community, and whatever I can do to give back to it, I feel I owe to the place.
Merby Posted July 23, 2008 Posted July 23, 2008 Move the challenge threads in to the particular strat forum they're associated to. They don't really belong in genpo - and maybe that would get some people active IN the strat forums just by being there all the time. Sticky a challenge thread at the top of each of the strat forums. Start some kind of community spirit for those playing each particular game. Start a heads up forum - seems that's the fastest growing segment of the online game today. I don't know about anyone else, but it frustrates me greatly to hear people say things like this:We have to remember that we all started somewhere. Once upon a time WE ALL were the newer player who didn't understand some concept or way of thinking. The world of online poker today is a much different place than it was even two or three years ago. Yeah, some of the strat posts are basic - it doesn't take a lot to put a short blurb about what the right play is AND the fact that it's a pretty standard concept. I try to comment one way or other on EVERY thread posted in the omaha forum.I give a MASSIVE amount of credit to this forum and some of the posters on it who have been good enough to share their knowledge with me. I've reached out to a few guys asking for help with certain things, and the vast majority of the time, I've cultivated not only a new wealth of poker knowledge, but what I feel to be a true friendship with that person.Recently, I've also had a few others approach me about learning low limit plo. I know I'm no grand wizard of the game, but I have a good understanding of the fundamentals and basic concepts. I try to do everything I can to help these players - I've even pm'd some that appear to be having trouble with some of the basics. I do this because I know what I've taken FROM this forum and community, and whatever I can do to give back to it, I feel I owe to the place.WOW bdc, that's gold.I agree completely --although I will miss posting PLO hands in the NLHE-dominated NewChallenge (Old Challenge) thread. On the other hand, the main challenge thread has hands from both holdem (limit, no limit and HU) and PLO, so perhaps it belongs as a stickied thread in the General Strategy forum and not any strategy subforum.
BaseJester Posted July 23, 2008 Posted July 23, 2008 I have KK and got min raised on the river? what do I do?Call.
Moneyball16 Posted July 23, 2008 Posted July 23, 2008 I like bdcs suggestion of puting the challenge threads in the strat forums.To be honest though I dont think there is much that can be done. I find myself at the 2+2 forums more and more just because they have such huge numbers and that they can support many different sub forums. For example I play almost 95% full ring NL now and when I come here I have to wade through hands that are either way lower than what I play or are 6-max as opposed to 2+2 where they have s specific full ring forums based on what limits you play and thats normally a better use of my time.FCP does have some advantages though in that it feels much more like a community here and that normally when I comment on somebodys hands or post hands with questions it wont be seen by people I play with everyday giving them more insight into how I think etc.
CobaltBlue Posted July 23, 2008 Posted July 23, 2008 Move the challenge threads in to the particular strat forum they're associated to. They don't really belong in genpo - and maybe that would get some people active IN the strat forums just by being there all the time. Sticky a challenge thread at the top of each of the strat forums. Start some kind of community spirit for those playing each particular game. Start a heads up forum - seems that's the fastest growing segment of the online game today.Did you see how much they freaked out when I got Zach to put a space in the title? =)No, but seriously, I like this idea...though I'm sure they'll try to mutiny.
FCP Bob Posted July 23, 2008 Posted July 23, 2008 The challenge threads are more than just strat and there is no way they will be moved from General Poker.In general the activity of strat forums in my opinion is driven by a few things. One is an influx of newer players who are anxious to learn and post a lot of questions. Since the FCP cardroom isn't operating any longer we don't have as many new people coming to the forums who are looking to learn. People may not realize it but the FCP cardroom had a much larger base of people than the forums do and some of those people trickled over to the forums as well.Maybe as the base of people using PokerVT increases that will drive some of them to also become active in the FCP Strat forums.
Acid_Knight Posted July 23, 2008 Posted July 23, 2008 I don't know about anyone else, but it frustrates me greatly to hear people say things like this:We have to remember that we all started somewhere. Once upon a time WE ALL were the newer player who didn't understand some concept or way of thinking. The world of online poker today is a much different place than it was even two or three years ago. Yeah, some of the strat posts are basic - it doesn't take a lot to put a short blurb about what the right play is AND the fact that it's a pretty standard concept. I try to comment one way or other on EVERY thread posted in the omaha forum.FWIW, I used to post in basically every thread in NL strat, even the ones that were the most standard of spots. It's really only in the last 6-8 months that I've started to not even bother opening the threads because I kind of feel like I'm not gonna gain anything from them and since the answer is often obvious or standard, someone else will fill in that spot. I still do open threads that are posted by certain posters or that have interesting titles, but overall, I think that a lot of the things that I used to do in here are kind of taken care of by other people. The strat forums dying is just a combination of fewer people who are gonna post good advice in the threads and the fact that the threads aren't often interesting enough to generate good discussion.
Acid_Knight Posted July 23, 2008 Posted July 23, 2008 Oh, and I'm sorry this took me so long:Royal TourWithout him, nothing drives the quality discussions in the strat forums.
Acid_Knight Posted July 23, 2008 Posted July 23, 2008 Your join date @ FCP is over 2 years old and you still play this way??this thread = lame potatoesI want to copy this post and put into all other threads in the forum.Irony?
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now